A study of 160 countries and 60 years of economic history reveals that no country has ever made the transition from poverty to prosperity without a high savings rate. And households, that is, us, have never made the transition. Most Important Contributors to the level of the country’s overall savings rate.
However, South Africa’s household savings rate is Only 0.5% – the lowest in the world. this is Far below In many emerging market countries, including Brazil, Chile and India, household savings rates are between 5 and 9 percent of gross domestic product.
Across the world, household savings do not remain “under the mattress” but generally serve as one of the main sources of financing domestic capital investment through banks and other financial institutions. This means that ultimately, your and my savings Funders The development of ports, highways, and hospitals will be major drivers of long-term economic growth, job creation, and increased incomes.
The two-part retirement plan is It has been introduced in South Africa Colloquially known as the “two-pot system,” the scheme is intended to help address the country’s savings shortfall. The change has important implications for people planning for retirement.
The new system, due to be introduced in South Africa on September 1, 2024, will apply to both private and public pensions, including the country’s largest fund, the Government Employees Pension Fund (GEPF).
The new system will introduce two components to an individual’s retirement savings.
This marks a dramatic change to the current system, where people are forced to withdraw all of their pension savings when they retire. The new regulations will remove the temptation to withdraw all of their savings when they change jobs, ensuring a better retirement life in the long run.
structure
The retirement or savings portion accounts for two-thirds of the contribution. Here, two-thirds of the amount an individual has saved towards retirement through a fund (not personal savings) must be put into this first fund.
This component is designed to save a portion of retirement funds for retirement. New regulations require this portion of an individual’s retirement savings to be held in this “pool”. No withdrawals are permitted until retirement age. The intention is to ensure that individuals have sufficient funds to support themselves in retirement and, in turn, provide the South African economy with a more stable and growing savings pool to fund economic growth and employment.
The savings portion, which accounts for one-third of your contributions, allows you to withdraw part of your retirement fund early, before you retire. This gives you the flexibility to meet unexpected financial needs. You can withdraw a minimum of 2,000 rand (110 US dollars) and there is no upper limit (depending on the amount of savings), but you can only withdraw once a year. Withdrawals from this second savings are taxed at the member’s marginal tax rate (the rate applicable to your last rand income) and may incur additional administration fees.
There is no doubt that South Africa is a country with a huge divide between the financially secure and the financially vulnerable. For those facing financial difficulties, the need to access funds set aside for retirement is very real.
The Gini coefficient is 63.0South Africa has one of the most unequal income distributions in the world, which is one of the reasons why proposals have been made to allow individuals to access part of their retirement savings in the event of an emergency.
While this makes some sense given the financial vulnerability of households, it could put their long-term savings at risk and does not impact employed or unemployed people who are not covered by a retirement plan.
But the tragedy is that the people who need to set aside funds up front are the very people who don’t need to — they’ll need all of their retirement savings to survive when they retire. 1 in 10 South Africans have enough money to maintain their standard of living in retirement, so what does this two-factor system mean for retirees and investors approaching retirement?
Pros and Cons
Under the new system, you cannot touch or spend the retirement benefit portion until you retire. This is a big advantage over the current system, where you receive the entire amount in cash when you retire. Less than 10% Whether people can retire financially.
In the future, more and more people will be saving at least two-thirds of their retirement assets. This not only benefits individuals by ensuring a permanent savings pool, but it also benefits the country, as it reduces reliance on government as this pool grows over time.
about 3.9 million In South Africa, the monthly Old Age Allowance (also known as the Old Age Allowance) is currently R2,080 per person per month. The researchers found that in most cases, this amount is Not enough to satisfy The needs of older people in South Africa.
The Treasury may also benefit from increased tax revenue, as any money withdrawn from the savings portion is taxed at the participant’s marginal tax rate.
Despite these positive points, I would like to point out two caveats.
-
The effect on an individual’s future wealth by eliminating the effect of compound interest (the accumulation of interest on investments over time).
-
South Africans tend to prioritise consumption over investment.
The purpose of a retirement system is to provide for your future self. Giving people early or premature access to their retirement assets permanently denies them the ability to provide for their future self.
Additionally, there are implications for South Africa, a savings-starved country. Most people retire without sufficient assets, meaning they are effectively facing “retirement bankruptcy.” There will be a huge temptation to tap into this pool of capital. To make matters worse, the main reason South Africans have found themselves in this situation is that they are biased towards consumption.
I worry that a disproportionate amount of the money coming out of retirement savings plans will be directed towards consumption rather than balance sheet management.
Alternative proposal
The new system could be better structured; several other models show how.
In Singapore, all Singaporean and permanent resident workers earning a monthly salary of at least 50 Singapore dollars (about 650 rand, equivalent to about 40 US dollars) are required to contribute to the Central Provident Fund, a defined contribution pension plan. Under this plan, employees and employers make regular contributions to employees’ individual accounts, and the amount employees receive upon retirement depends on the investment performance of those contributions over time, but importantly, the full amount is returned to the employee.
under Singapore PlanEmployers are required to contribute to the fund in an amount roughly matching employee contributions.
This discipline helps individuals save enough for retirement. The Central Provident Fund encourages long-term savings for retirement while allowing flexible withdrawals for specific purposes like housing, healthcare, education etc. It provides a safety net against unexpected expenses but not against reckless consumption.
of Chile’s pension systemThe pension scheme introduced in 1981 is widely seen as a successful model, with a move from pay-as-you-go to individual retirement accounts, which significantly increased national savings and improved the financial security of retirees.
Under this system, workers are required to contribute a certain percentage of their income to individual retirement accounts managed by private pension funds, called Administradoras de Fondos de Pensiones.
Despite its success in many areas, the system has come under criticism for not adequately addressing income inequality and for the low pensions some members receive. There have also been concerns about high administration fees charged by pension funds and inequality in retirement living. Still, Chilean pensioners are materially better off today than they were in the early 1980s.
What next?
Diverse countries India (10.8%) and Chile (9.7%) We have achieved savings rates that call into question the assumption that households in low-income countries cannot save. Indeed, the experience of many countries proves this idea nonsense.
Auto-enrolment (compulsory savings) is expected to be the ‘next big thing’ to happen in the retirement industry, with huge benefits for individuals, the retirement sector and the country.
This is the first of four articles on changes to South Africa’s pension system.