Here’s the scenario: The government has confirmed that NASA astronomers have detected a never-before-seen asteroid moving toward Earth at high speed. The asteroid will take 14 years to reach Earth, but there is a 72 percent chance that it will directly impact Earth on July 12, 2038. Little information is known, but observers believe the asteroid ranges from 80 to 800 meters (262 to 2,624 feet) in diameter. Either way, it would be enough to cause catastrophic death and destruction. To make matters worse, the asteroid will pass behind the Sun from Earth’s perspective, meaning experts won’t be able to conduct any additional critical assessments for at least the next seven months. What would you do?
That was the hypothetical dilemma posed by NASA and FEMA recently at the fifth biennial Planetary Defense Interagency Tabletop Exercise, held at the Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory (APL) in Laurel, Maryland. The first outline was published It will be released on June 20th, with a “full post-mortem report” due to be released later this year.
A catastrophic asteroid or comet hitting Earth is rare but inevitable, and while the near certainty of another Earth impact is unsettling, there’s at least a small silver lining to it compared to other major environmental crises.
“A large asteroid impact may be the only natural disaster that humanity can predict years in advance and take precautions for,” said Lindley Johnson, Planetary Defense Officer Emeritus at NASA. According to a statement from the agency: On Thursday.
With that in mind, about 100 representatives from government agencies, companies, and watchdog groups, including the U.S. State Department, the Smithsonian Institution, the European Space Agency, and the University of Cambridge, met over two days in Maryland this spring to outline the strengths and weaknesses of current international authorities in the face of such great global uncertainty. Unlike previous space hazard tabletop exercises, however, the teams were equipped with a key new resource: data from NASA’s Dual Asteroid Reorientation Test (DART) mission.
After a seven-million-mile journey, the car-sized, $325 million DART spacecraft was to intentionally crash into the 525-foot-wide asteroid Dimorphos on September 26, 2022, while orbiting its parent meteor, Didymos. NASA had previously estimated DART had about a 10 percent success rate, but the spacecraft made a deadly landing while traveling at about 14,000 miles per hour, creating a wide crater in the process and spewing two million pounds of debris into space. Initially, the procedure was described as “a scare tactic.”Crash a golf cart into the Great PyramidAccording to the report, the DART mission permanently altered the course of Dimorphos, making a far-fetched science fiction concept into reality.
Armed with extensive information from DART, the Crisis Scenario Team set out to determine what international cooperation could and could not accomplish at this time in the face of an imminent asteroid impact. Participants established the outlines of an ideal response plan ahead of the anticipated 2038 impact date, noting that “timelines for space mission planning, disaster management, information sharing, and communications are intertwined in ways that were not fully appreciated initially.”
After waiting for more information after the asteroid re-emerged from behind the sun, team members decided to first plan a $200-400 million flyby mission led by NASA and encourage similar missions by international space agencies. Once specific data and a trajectory were established, a second $800-1 billion “dedicated rendezvous” mission would be launched, an enhanced successor to DART to nudge the asteroid out of Earth’s orbit.
Of course, experts acknowledge that there are many hurdles to overcome in any international coordinated effort. One of the main problems at home will be that the U.S. Congress is likely not to act until the impact is certain. Similarly, until convincing evidence of an imminent threat is presented, it may be difficult to extract funds from the government to prevent a possible tragedy. This is a clear problem, considering that time is of the essence, even with warnings 14 years in advance. And there will almost certainly be a wave of disinformation and misinformation that will have to be debunked for the public.
[Related: 5 ways we know DART crushed that asteroid (but not literally)]
Another limiting factor is that “kinetic energy impact” missions like DART are the only potential solution that have been fully tested in space. Experts stressed that it is in humanity’s best interest that additional possible solutions be researched and demonstrated, such as: Ion Beam Technology.
Despite the many challenges, post-exercise participant surveys were somewhat positive: About 75% of respondents believed humanity was sufficiently prepared to carry out necessary reconnaissance missions. That said, only half of those surveyed reportedly believed international leaders were prepared to carry out an Earth collision prevention mission.
At the very least, future projects are already underway to better understand and prepare for potential space collisions. NASA is currently Near Earth Object (NEO) probeis an infrared telescope dedicated to finding, classifying, and characterizing potentially hazardous space rocks years before they pose a threat. The NEO Surveyor is scheduled to launch in June 2028, but additional tabletop exercises are already in the works to continue training emergency experts on how to best respond to such a frightening (and unfortunately possible) situation.